Fall Apple Cider Hot Toddy

Fall Apple Cider Hot Toddy

A hot toddy is medicine in a mug — warm, honey-sweet, and spiked just enough to loosen your shoulders. This fall version uses fresh apple cider as the base instead of plain hot water, which makes it taste like autumn in a cup. Sip it when the evenings get cold and you need something that warms from

1 cocktail
Yield
10 minutes
Time
Spiced cider base (without alcohol) can be made in a large batch and stored refrigerated for 4 days. Reheat gently and add spirits per mug when serving. Great for parties.
Keeps

A hot toddy is medicine in a mug — warm, honey-sweet, and spiked just enough to loosen your shoulders. This fall version uses fresh apple cider as the base instead of plain hot water, which makes it taste like autumn in a cup. Sip it when the evenings get cold and you need something that warms from

Ingredients

Method

  1. **Heat the cider.** Pour the apple cider into a small saucepan with the cinnamon stick, cloves, ginger, and star anise. Warm over medium-low heat until steaming and just below a simmer — about 5 minutes. Don't boil (it concentrates the tannins and turns the cider harsh).
  2. **Dissolve the honey.** Add the honey to the warm cider and stir until fully dissolved.
  3. **Strain and combine.** Strain the spiced cider into a warmed mug (run the mug under hot water first to pre-heat it). Add the bourbon and lemon juice. Stir.
  4. **Garnish** with a cinnamon stick, star anise, and a thin apple slice floated on top.
  5. **Drink slowly.** This isn't a shot — it's a ritual.
  6. *Variations:**
  7. **Classic Hot Toddy**: Replace the apple cider with 6 oz hot water. Increase honey to 2 tablespoons.
  8. **Ginger Hot Toddy**: Add 1 oz fresh ginger juice (grate ginger and squeeze through cheesecloth) and reduce cider to 5 oz.
  9. **Rum Toddy**: Replace bourbon with dark rum (Appleton Estate or Mount Gay).
  10. *Storage:** Spiced cider base (without alcohol) can be made in a large batch and stored refrigerated for 4 days. Reheat gently and add spirits per mug when serving. Great for parties.

This recipe is from The Bar

See What's Inside →
· · ·

We started Gathered Guides because drinks deserve better than neon-colored mixers and corn syrup. The Bar is for anyone who wants their cocktail hour to taste like something real.

250+
recipes across 11 cookbooks — 789 pages of kitchen wisdom
📖

No SEO Filler

Just the recipe. No 2,000-word life story before the ingredients list.

🍳

Tested in Real Kitchens

Every recipe was made, adjusted, and made again until it worked perfectly at home.

🎁

Beautiful Enough to Gift

Designed to feel like something you'd find in a bookshop — not printed from a blog.

The Bar

The Bar

25+ recipes
  • Seasonal cocktails & mocktails
  • Garden-to-glass drinks
  • Foraged sips & shrubs
  • Real ingredients, real drinks
Get The Bar — $12.99
Instant PDF download
From Scratch Staples The Bar

Kitchen Foundations 2-Pack

65+ recipes
  • From Scratch Staples
  • The Bar
$25.98 $17.99 Save 31%
Get the Kitchen Foundations 2-Pack
From Scratch Staples Fermented & Cultured Homemade Replacements The Apothecary Kitchen Sweets, Candies & Treats Global Kitchen The Bar

The Whole Kitchen

Everything your kitchen needs
  • From Scratch Staples
  • Fermented & Cultured
  • Homemade Replacements
  • The Apothecary Kitchen
  • Sweets, Candies & Treats
  • Global Kitchen
  • The Bar
+ FREE: The Bar ($12.99 value)
$90.93 $47
Save 48%
Get The Whole Kitchen — $47
Instant PDF download — all 7 books
From Scratch Staples The Bar
  • From Scratch Staples
  • The Bar

Kitchen Foundations 2-Pack

$17.99
$25.98 — save 31%
Get It Now →
🔒 Secure checkout via Stripe

Or get everything:

The Whole Kitchen — $47 (save 48%)

Instant PDF download. No subscriptions. No hidden fees.

🔒 Secure checkout
📱 Works on any device
🌿 Made in BC

Free Guide — No Credit Card

Get it here free — 20 herbs your kitchen already has

Fire cider, elderberry gummies, garlic tonic & more. Yours free — no strings attached.

We respect your inbox. One guide, then we're done.